Moral Question? Do we Side With the Activists, Ranchers, or the Wild Horses? Reader Comments Welcome

Stand off in the Sagebrush Obstructs Pioneering Efforts for Wild Horses

Mustang 4 4 inchesEUREKA, NV = On February 13, 2015, the wild horse roundup began on the Fish Creek Herd Management Area in Eureka, Nevada. After six days, 424 horses were captured.

Plans to re-release 186 wild horses back onto their range Saturday morning are being blocked in a stand off on Highway 50.  Eureka County Commission has filed an IBLA appeal (Interior Board of Land Appeals) on behalf of livestock rancher Kevin Borba. Borba has a grazing permit on the Herd Management Area (HMA). Eureka County Commission is demanding that the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) ship all the horses to the government holding facility in Palomino Valley, Nevada.

BLM’s intent is to proceed with their gather plan as published which includes the re-release of the horses. For now, 197 horses await an uncertain fate pending a review of the appeal filed by Eureka County with the IBLA. The result of a 2013 national public survey revealed that seventy –two percent of Americans want wild horses protected as living symbols of our western heritage.

Borba, a fairly recent transplant from California, is not new to media attention. In April 2014, he was a very vocal supporter of “trespass cattle rancher” Cliven Bundy. Borba, also in trespass by grazing his cattle without paying his grazing lease fees, rallied supporters for Bundy on guerilla media, while claiming to be a victim of the federal government himself.

The groundbreaking Fish Creek Management Plan, now in jeopardy, calls for the release of 186 horses back onto their range with 104 of the mares now treated with a non-hormonal contraceptive vaccine.

The Fish Creek Management Plan is designed around recommendations released in 2013 by the National Academy of Sciences after a two-year study commissioned by the National BLM Program Office for over $1 million and funded by the American taxpayer. The progressive management plan is the result of a ten-year management strategy. The plan was forged to support fiscally responsible humane and effective methods to minimize the unsustainable capture and warehousing of wild horses. The plan also incorporates data collection as recommended by the National Academy of Sciences findings, such as identifying genetic health, seasonal movement, impact to herd structure, and range-use patterns.

The unique environment at the Fish Creek Herd Management Area encompasses 230,000 square acres and will be the largest area for native PZP contraception to be used as part of an on-going study in on-the-range management. The herd is an extremely healthy and diverse population of wild horses, including the largest population of rare Curlys, which make up 16% of the herd.

The horses are caught in the middle of the ongoing historic battle between the federal government and public land ranchers. Borba and his fellow public land ranchers dismiss the impact of the four-year drought when faced with livestock grazing restrictions dictated by the federal government.

“The management plan for Fish Creek is an inspiring step forward for all the dedicated advocates, ranchers and government employees that have worked hard for years on solutions that will keep our wild horses on the range!”, said Neda DeMayo, President of Return to Freedom, a wild horse conservation organization. “While proven effective and safe management methods are delayed, the real battle rages on. As America’s wild horses face their last stand, we need solutions that work for range resources, the ranchers and our wild horses—now.”

Laura Leigh, founder of Wild Horse Education, a supporter of the Fish Creek Management Plan, has been on site throughout the roundup and will volunteer to help with the adoption of the 232 younger horses removed from the range. “ I have been documenting the Fish Creek range and this herd for years, as well as the trespass cattle here. We finally have a fair and sane management plan that makes sense for today. To lose ground in a stand off reminiscent of an old Western movie will be a giant step backwards,” Leigh said.

Tragically, as drought continues to impact rangelands and wilderness areas across the west, ranchers target the wild horses for removal even when they are outnumbered by livestock an average of thirty-five to one. Ironically, the public land rancher clings to a sense of ownership of our public lands, rooted in a culture that is disappearing along with our wild horses.

BLM estimates 45 million acres of Nevada’s public land is available for livestock grazing. An estimated 25,000 wild horses and burros currently exist on under 16 million acres of Nevada’s public lands, which they share with between 240,000 – 480,000 livestock. The systematic removals of wild horses and burros currently accounts for 48,000 wild horses and burros in government holding facilities, costing taxpayers almost $70 million annually.

Return to Freedom (RTF) is a national non-profit dedicated to wild horse preservation through sanctuary, education and conservation. RTF advocates for the redirection of funds used for roundups and holding to minimally invasive on-the-range management solutions.

Wild Horse Education (WHE) educates the public about the plight of wild horses and burros and works to end the inhumane treatment of these heritage animals through a scientifically based management strategy in the wild.